Diversification Dilemma – A Key Account Mini-Case

Strategic account relationships often involve tough choices — especially when your customer’s needs evolve beyond your core capabilities. In this mini-case, we follow SNT, a medium-sized IT services provider, as they face a pivotal decision: whether to diversify into outsourcing in order to retain a key government client.

With system upgrades overdue, civil service pressure building, and a massive outsourcing contract on the horizon, SNT must decide whether to stretch their model — or step back and risk losing the relationship entirely.

Scenario Overview

  • SNT has a successful five-year track record with a UK government department
  • Despite positive board-level relations, user satisfaction is slipping
  • A new outsourcing contract will transfer staff, systems, and accountability to the winning bidder
  • SNT is invited to a stakeholder meeting to assess the opportunity — and stake their claim

Strategic Challenge

The key account manager must balance:

  • Client retention vs. business model integrity
  • Speed vs. strategic due diligence
  • Partnership vs. direct competition with global outsourcing firms

Outcome & Lessons

  • SNT ultimately declines to bid for the contract, citing strategic misalignment
  • They partner with the winning consultancy and are eventually acquired by them
  • Had SNT built deeper internal networks and KAM structures earlier, they might have been better positioned

Discussion Use

  • How does your organisation decide when to stretch or pivot?
  • What are the risks of reacting too slowly to major client shifts?
  • Would you have handled the stakeholder meeting differently?

Insight

“Strategic accounts evolve — and when they do, so must your account strategy. What looks like diversification may simply be survival.” – Professor Malcolm McDonald

Download the Mini-Case

This summary outlines the core challenge, but the full PDF includes the narrative, discussion, and strategic recommendations for facilitation or team reflection.

📥 Download the full PDF

Reproduced with kind permission from Dr Beth Rogers.